Home                  

Criticism Index

Apollo and Marsyas

The flaying of Marsyas, by Titian (1575)
In Greek Myth, the satyr Marsyas was so proud of his playing on the flute that the God Apollo challenged him to a music contest.  The God played his lyre while Marsyas continued on his flute.  After some trickery by the God, the Muses awarded victory to Apollo.  Apollo then took revenge for the effrontery of Marsyas by flaying him alive and pinning up the removed skin on a pine tree.
The real duel of Apollo
with Marsyas
(perfect ear
versus immense range)
is held at dusk
when as we already know
the judges have already awarded victory to the god

tightly bound to a tree
meticulously flayed of his skin
Marsyas
shouts
before the shout reaches
his tall ears
he rests in the shadow of that shout

shuddering with disgust
Apollo is cleaning his instrument

only apparently
is the voice of Marsyas
monotonous
and composed of a single vowel
A

in reality
Marsyas
tells
of the inexhaustible wealth
of his body

bald mountains of liver
white ravines of aliment
rustling forests of lung
sweet hills of muscle
joints bile blood and shudders
the wintry wind of the bone
over the salt of memory

shuddering with disgust
Apollo is cleaning his instrument

now to the chorus
is joined the backbone of Marsyas
in principle the same A
only deeper with the addition of rust

this is beyond the endurance
of the god with nerves of plastic

              along a gravel path
              hedged with box-trees
              the victor departs
              wondering
              whether out of Marsyas' howling
              will not one day arise
              a new kind
              of art - let us say - concrete

suddenly
at his feet falls
a petrified nightingale

he turns his head
and sees
that the tree to which Marsyas was tied
is white

completely 


                              (Zbigniew Herbert (1957)
                                                translated by
                                                   John and Bogdana Carpenter )
top    commentary(to be done)             index Home